Purpose and Scope
- Any employee who has a grievance is entitled to use this policy. The policy exists so that grievances are resolved fairly, quickly and at the earliest possible stage.
- A grievance is any feeling of dissatisfaction or perceived unfair treatment that an employee has about their work or employment.
- This policy may not be used to address a demand to change salary, wages or benefits, or as an appeal mechanism following a disciplinary hearing.
Protection and Confidentiality
- An employee may lodge a grievance without fear of victimisation.
- Sparrows must not victimise an employee representative for advising or representing an employee who lodges a grievance. Where an employee suspects victimisation, they may submit the details under this policy.
- A grievance is handled with discretion. Sparrows protects the confidentiality and privacy of the employees concerned.
General Principles
- A formal grievance hearing need not be convened for every grievance. An informal meeting between the employee and their supervisor is often the best way to resolve a minor complaint. It also encourages direct communication between staff and management. A formal hearing is convened where the employee requests it or the Executive Director decides the grievance is serious.
- Where the employee requests a formal hearing, or the Executive Director decides the grievance is serious, the employee must set out the complaint in writing. This makes clear what the grievance is and what resolution is wanted. The employee lodges it under §4.1.
- Once a formal grievance is lodged under §3.2, the Executive Director convenes a formal hearing into the facts of the case. The hearing follows these rules:
- The Executive Director appoints a Hearing Chairperson for the grievance hearing, per §4.3.
- The Hearing Chairperson sets the time, date and venue of the grievance hearing.
- The employee has the right to request an interpreter, which Sparrows must then provide.
- The employee, and any representative under §3.3.7, have the right to present their case and lead evidence. They also have the right to call and question witnesses, and to have copies of any documents produced as evidence at the hearing. The Hearing Chairperson may ask for more evidence or witnesses to decide the merits of the grievance.
- After hearing all available evidence, the Hearing Chairperson makes a finding on the merits, decides any appropriate remedial action, and communicates the decision to all parties in writing.
- A person the Hearing Chairperson appoints keeps a record of the proceedings.
- The employee is entitled to be represented by another Sparrows employee, but must arrange this representation themselves.
- Where a group grievance is raised, at most two observers (including the grievants) may attend the hearing in addition to any representatives. Further grievants may be called into the hearing one at a time to present their case.
- Where the grievance is not resolved to the employee's satisfaction, the employee is entitled to proceed to the next stage.
Stages of the Grievance Procedure
- Stage One
- An employee who believes they have a grievance reports it to their supervisor. Where §3.2 applies, the employee does so in writing, on the Lodging of Grievance Form.
- Where §3.2 does not apply, the supervisor tries to resolve the grievance and tells the employee the outcome as soon as possible. Where §3.2 applies, the supervisor gives the Lodging of Grievance Form to the Executive Director, who convenes a hearing under §3.3 and appoints the Hearing Chairperson under §4.3. A supervisor who considers a grievance serious refers it to the Executive Director without delay. Once a decision has been given and the employee wants to pursue the matter further, Stage Two applies.
- Where an employee's complaint is about their immediate supervisor, they raise it with the next reporting level up instead.
- Stage Two
- If the employee proceeds after Stage One, or chooses to begin at Stage Two without going through Stage One, they lodge the grievance with the Executive Director. A representative under §3.3.7 may assist them. The Executive Director appoints a Hearing Chairperson of the same or higher status as any Stage One Hearing Chairperson, under §4.3, and convenes a formal grievance hearing under §3.3.
- Once the Hearing Chairperson has given a decision and the employee wants to pursue the matter further, the employee has the right to pursue it under the Labour Relations Act, 1995 (see §6).
- Appointing the Hearing Chairperson. The Executive Director appoints the Hearing Chairperson of a grievance hearing. The Hearing Chairperson must not be a person already involved in the grievance, and must not have formed a view on its outcome. The Executive Director may appoint the Employment Dispute Officer. Where the grievance concerns a decision of the Executive Director, or the employee raising the grievance is the Executive Director, every reference in this policy to the Executive Director is read instead as a reference to the Chairperson. This is the same escalation rule that Disciplinary Code and Procedure §1.5 applies, so that a grievance is never decided by the person it is about.
- A grievance about a Board member, other than the Executive Director or the Chairperson, is lodged with the Executive Director. The Executive Director then liaises with the Chairperson to decide what happens next. A grievance about the Chairperson is lodged with the Vice-Chairperson. If it reaches the Executive Director first, the Executive Director passes it to the Vice-Chairperson at once. The Vice-Chairperson liaises with the Secretary to convene a full Board meeting, and chairs that meeting, not the Chairperson. The Executive Director takes no part in the matter, unless the Board asks the Executive Director for information on the matter complained about.
The Grievance Form
- The employee completes the Lodging of Grievance Form, with all relevant documentation, before a formal hearing begins at either stage. At Stage One the employee gives it to their supervisor under §4.1. At Stage Two the employee submits it to the Executive Director (or, per §4.3, the Chairperson, or, for a grievance about the Chairperson under §4.4, the Vice-Chairperson).
- Three standard forms support this policy: the Lodging of Grievance Form, the Notice of Grievance Hearing Form and the Finding of Grievance Hearing Form.
Grievances Not Resolved
- A grievance that is not resolved to the employee's satisfaction under this policy may be taken further under the Labour Relations Act, 1995 (Act 66 of 1995). The usual step is a referral to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA).
- Lodging a grievance under this policy does not stop the time limits in the Labour Relations Act, 1995 from running. An employee who alleges an unfair labour practice must refer the dispute to the CCMA within 90 days of the act or omission (section 191(1)(b)(ii)). If the employee became aware of it later, the 90 days run from then. This applies whether or not a grievance is still open. The CCMA may allow a late referral if the employee shows good cause (section 191(2)).
Time Limits
- The time periods within which each stage begins are set out below. They may be varied having regard to the circumstances of a particular case, subject to fairness and reasonableness.
Procedural Step Time Period Form Stage 1 Lodging of Grievance Within 7 calendar days of the incident giving rise to the grievance Lodging of Grievance Form Notice of Grievance Hearing Within 3 calendar days of lodgement Notice of Grievance Hearing Form Grievance Hearing Within 4 calendar days of notification to attend — Finding of Grievance Hearing Within 7 calendar days of the hearing Finding of Grievance Hearing Form Stage 2 Lodging of Grievance Within 7 calendar days of the Stage 1 finding or, where Stage 1 is not used, of the incident giving rise to the grievance Lodging of Grievance Form Notice of Grievance Hearing Within 3 calendar days of lodgement Notice of Grievance Hearing Form Grievance Hearing Within 4 calendar days of notification to attend — Finding of Grievance Hearing Within 7 calendar days of the hearing Finding of Grievance Hearing Form
Relationship to the Disciplinary Code and Procedure
- This policy and the Disciplinary Code and Procedure are companion documents, not overlapping ones. This policy is for an employee's complaint about how they have been treated. The Disciplinary Code and Procedure is for a concern about an employee's own conduct. Neither is a route of appeal against the other: §1.3 and Disciplinary Code and Procedure §1.2 each say so from their own side.
- Both documents use the same escalation rule. Where the person who would ordinarily decide is the subject of the matter, the next level up decides instead. This ends with the Chairperson where the grievance concerns the Executive Director or is raised by them. Read §4.3 and §4.4 alongside Disciplinary Code and Procedure §1.5–1.7 for the complete picture of either document.
Review
- This policy is reviewed annually by the Board.