Purpose and scope
- This Code sets out how Sparrows deals with a concern about a member of staff's conduct, from an informal word through to dismissal. It applies to every Sparrows employee, permanent and temporary. A concern about a volunteer, contractor or tutor is dealt with under §9.2 to §9.4 of the Code of Conduct for Staff and Volunteers, which applies §5 of this Code to a child-safety matter.
- This Code is separate from, and does not replace, the Grievance Policy. The Grievance Policy is for an employee's complaint about how they have been treated. This Code is for a concern about an employee's own conduct. The Grievance Policy already excludes "an appeal mechanism following a disciplinary hearing," and nothing in this Code changes that. It is also separate from the steps the Human Resource Policy sets for poor work performance (§10.3 of that policy), which is a matter of capacity and not of conduct.
- This Code is also separate from, and does not replace, the mandatory child-protection reporting duties that apply to every employee — the duty to report suspected abuse or neglect, the separate duty triggered by a suspected sexual offence against a child, and the internal duty to report a reportable incident. Those duties apply on their own terms, to the individual employee who forms the relevant belief, regardless of anything in this Code. Where a concern about a staff member's conduct also meets the threshold for one of those duties, the duty is discharged in full, on its own timeline — see §5.
- The safeguarding-specific provisions of this Code — §§5, 6 and 8 in particular — are also covered in staff induction and training, in plain language, alongside this Code's own more formal terms.
- Where a concern under this Code involves the Executive Director, or the Executive Director is otherwise unable to act, every reference in this Code to the Executive Director is read instead as a reference to the Chairperson. The Chairperson then decides interim measures under §5, appoints the Hearing Chairperson under §7.3, and receives the hearing decision under §7.6, in the Executive Director's place. The Executive Director is not a Board member.
- A concern about a Board member, other than the Executive Director or the Chairperson, is reported to the Executive Director in the usual way. The Executive Director then liaises directly with the Chairperson to decide what happens next. This Code governs Sparrows' employees; how the Board itself deals with a concern about one of its own members is a governance matter for the Board, and this Code does not prescribe it further.
- A concern about the Chairperson is reported to the Vice-Chairperson. If it reaches the Executive Director first, the Executive Director passes it to the Vice-Chairperson at once. The Vice-Chairperson gives it in writing to the Secretary. The Secretary tells every Board member. A special meeting of the Board is called on the written request of any three Board members (Constitution, clause 10.3.7), and the Secretary gives at least seven days' notice of it (clause 10.3.2). The Chairperson steps out of the meeting for this matter, so the Vice-Chairperson chairs it, as clause 10.3.4 provides when the Chairperson is absent. The Executive Director takes no part in the matter, unless the Board asks the Executive Director for information on the matter complained about. This is the one case under this Code where a matter goes to the whole Board, rather than being handled by a single office-holder standing in for another.
Guiding principles
- Correction before punishment, as the default. The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal says discipline is primarily corrective, through graduated measures (item 6(2)). Most conduct issues are resolved through guidance, a clear conversation and, where that fails, the graduated warnings in §4, not through dismissal.
- Except where the conduct itself rules that out. The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal recognises that serious misconduct, which may be a single instance, can make the continuation of the employment relationship intolerable (item 7). §6 of this Code sets out when that applies at Sparrows, and it is drawn narrowly, on purpose: it exists for conduct that endangers a child, not for ordinary performance or attitude problems.
- A fair process matters as much as a fair outcome. Every disciplinary step in this Code — however serious the alleged conduct — gives the employee a real chance to know what is alleged, to prepare, to be supported, and to be heard by someone who has not already decided the outcome. This is not a formality. It is what makes a finding, in either direction, one that can actually be trusted.
- A child's safety comes first, provably and without exception, while any of this is still being worked out. Where a concern touches a child's safety, interim measures under §5 are taken immediately and are never delayed by, or made conditional on, this Code's own procedural steps.
Categories of misconduct and the general sanction ladder
- Minor misconduct — a first, low-level issue: lateness, a missed task, a minor lapse in a routine. Dealt with informally wherever possible: a direct conversation with the Senior Child and Youth Care Worker or Social Worker, recorded briefly in the employee's file, with no hearing required.
- Moderate misconduct — a repeated minor issue, or a single issue more serious than §3.1 but short of §3.3: for example, an unexplained absence, a failure to complete required records, or a breach of a lesser workplace rule. Dealt with through the warning ladder in §4.
- Serious misconduct — for example, a serious breach of a safety procedure that did not in fact endanger a child, dishonesty short of gross dishonesty, or a serious breakdown in professional conduct toward a colleague. May justify a final written warning on a first occurrence, or dismissal where the circumstances in §3.5 point that way, following the full hearing procedure in §7.
- Gross misconduct (always including a child-safety matter, under §6) — dismissal is a fair sanction even on a first occurrence, following the full hearing procedure in §7. Examples, without limiting the general definition: any child-safety matter; gross dishonesty; theft or wilful damage to Sparrows' property; physical assault on a child, colleague or visitor; being under the influence of alcohol or drugs while on duty; gross insubordination; and a serious breach of Sparrows' confidentiality rules for a child's information that exposes that child to real harm.
- Choosing the sanction. Whatever the category, the person or Hearing Chairperson deciding a sanction must weigh these factors (Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, items 8 to 10):
- whether the employee broke a valid and reasonable rule or standard that the employee knew of, or could reasonably be expected to have known of;
- the importance of the rule and the actual or potential harm caused;
- the seriousness and circumstances of the conduct itself;
- the employee's length of service, disciplinary record and personal circumstances, including the effect of dismissal on the employee;
- the nature of the role and, specifically, its bearing on the safety of children in Sparrows' care;
- whether graduated measures might prevent a recurrence;
- any acknowledgement of wrongdoing and willingness to comply with Sparrows' rules; and
- consistency: as a general rule, Sparrows applies dismissal in the way it has applied it to other employees in the past, and consistently between employees who took part in the same misconduct.
- Notice on dismissal. A dismissal for gross misconduct under §3.4 takes effect on the date of the Hearing Chairperson's decision, without notice and without pay instead of notice. Section 37(6)(b) of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act preserves an employer's right to terminate a contract without notice for any cause recognised by law, and gross misconduct, as the Policies Guideline defines it, is misconduct that makes continuing the employment relationship intolerable (Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, item 7(1)). The employee is still paid what is due up to the date of dismissal, including pay for leave not taken (Human Resource Policy §13.6). A dismissal for serious misconduct under §3.3 is on notice (Human Resource Policy §13.2).
The warning ladder, for misconduct short of §3.4
- Stage 1 — informal correction. A direct conversation, not a hearing. Recorded briefly in the employee's file.
- Stage 2 — verbal warning. Given for a repeated Stage 1 issue, or a first issue serious enough to warrant it. Confirmed to the employee in writing within 3 business days, and valid for 3 months.
- Stage 3 — written warning. Given for a repeated issue after a verbal warning, or a first issue of moderate seriousness. Valid for 6 months.
- Stage 4 — final written warning. Given for a repeated issue after a written warning, or a single instance of serious misconduct under §3.3. Valid for 12 months. A final written warning is issued only after the hearing procedure in §7, because of what it exposes the employee to if breached again.
- A warning that has expired under §4.2 to §4.4 may not be relied on to justify a harsher sanction for a new, unrelated issue. It may still be considered as part of the employee's overall record where the new issue is a continuation or repetition of the same underlying problem.
- None of these stages apply to a child-safety matter. §6 governs that case from the outset.
Interim measures and investigation
- Where a concern is raised that may affect a child's safety, the Executive Director decides, immediately, what interim step is needed — which may include changing a roster, adjusting supervision so the employee is not left alone with the child or children concerned, or suspending the employee from duty. This decision is made on the recommendation of the Employment Dispute Officer, wherever that recommendation can practically be obtained in the time available; where it cannot, the Executive Director acts first and confirms with the Employment Dispute Officer as soon as possible afterward.
- A decision under this heading is a precaution, not a finding and not a sanction. It is made on the information available at the time, before an investigation or hearing has run its course, and it carries no presumption about the outcome.
- Suspension under this heading is on full pay, for the duration of the investigation and any hearing that follows, unless and until a disciplinary finding is made against the employee.
- The Executive Director reviews an interim measure under this heading when the investigation report is received, when notice of a hearing is given and when the Hearing Chairperson decides, and lifts it as soon as it is no longer needed, whatever the eventual outcome of the matter.
- Where a concern about serious or gross misconduct does not touch a child's safety, for example theft, fraud or gross dishonesty, the Executive Director may take an interim measure of the kind §5.1 lists, after consulting the Employment Dispute Officer where that can practicably be done. The measure may include suspending the employee on full pay, changing the employee's duties, or removing the employee's access to money, records or systems. It is taken only where the employee's presence could interfere with the investigation or put Sparrows' property, money or records at risk. §5.2 to §5.4 apply to it.
- Investigation. Where a concern is raised, the Executive Director decides within 5 business days whether it needs investigating. Minor misconduct under §3.1 is dealt with as that clause says, without an investigation. Otherwise the Executive Director investigates, or appoints someone to investigate, which may be the Employment Dispute Officer. The investigation need not be formal, but it gives the employee a fair opportunity to respond to the allegation (Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, item 11(2) and (3)).
- The investigation is completed within 21 calendar days of the decision to investigate, and its findings are given to the Executive Director in writing, unless the Executive Director records on the employee's file why more time is needed.
- The person who investigates does not chair the hearing (§7.3). Where the findings show a case to answer, the Executive Director gives notice under §7.1 within 5 business days of receiving them. Where they do not, the Executive Director tells the employee in writing that no further action will be taken.
Child-safety matters: no warning ladder, and why
- A child-safety matter goes straight to a formal disciplinary hearing under §7. It does not pass through §4's stages, on a first occurrence or otherwise. This is a deliberate departure from the general principle in §2.1, made for the reason §2.2 states: this is exactly the conduct South African labour law itself recognises as incompatible with continued employment, and Sparrows' overriding duty is to the safety of the children in its care.
- This clause governs the disciplinary sanction. It does not govern the reporting duty. Whether or not a disciplinary hearing is ever held, the mandatory child-protection reporting duties apply on their own terms, to the individual employee who formed the relevant belief or suspicion, on their own timeline — immediately, and never contingent on this Code's process. See §1.3.
- The two processes run at the same time. Where a report has also been made to the police, Sparrows' own hearing proceeds independently. Neither process waits for the other, and neither substitutes for the other.
- A finding of gross misconduct in a child-safety matter is ordinarily dismissal. The Hearing Chairperson may only depart from that where the individual circumstances genuinely make a lesser sanction fair — this is expected to be rare, given what the definition of a child-safety matter already requires to bring a matter within this clause at all.
The formal disciplinary hearing
- Notice. The employee is given written notice of the specific allegations, in language they can reasonably understand, with reasonable time to prepare — normally at least 48 hours, longer where the matter is complex. The notice states the date, time and place of the hearing, and that the hearing may proceed in the employee's absence if they do not attend despite having received proper notice.
- Representation. The employee may be represented or supported by a fellow employee or a registered trade union representative, at the employee's choice. Where reasonably possible, the employee may speak at the hearing in a language the employee is comfortable with (Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, item 11(4)).
- The Hearing Chairperson. The Executive Director appoints an independent Hearing Chairperson for the hearing — someone who did not raise or receive the original concern, is not a witness to the events in question, and has not already reached a view on the outcome. Sparrows may be represented at the hearing by the Employment Dispute Officer or another person the Executive Director designates. A hearing may be conducted by video call or another remote means where that suits the people involved better than meeting in person, provided every participant can hear and be heard, and nothing in this clause requires everyone to be in the same room.
- Postponement and amendment. A hearing may be postponed for good cause, including to allow further investigation or to add a charge that has since come to light. Any postponement and any amended charge is confirmed to the employee in writing.
- The hearing itself. Both sides may lead evidence, call and question witnesses, and make submissions. Where a child's evidence is involved, the hearing takes the same care with a child's account and wellbeing that Sparrows requires of an individual employee handling a report of a sexual offence against a child — a child is not required to give evidence in person where a fair alternative exists, and Sparrows' confidentiality protections for a child's information apply throughout.
- The decision. The Hearing Chairperson decides the matter on the evidence presented, applying the standard of a fair employer under the Labour Relations Act, and gives the decision in writing, with reasons, to the employee and to the Executive Director within 5 business days of the end of the hearing.
- Where an employee fails to attend a properly noticed hearing, the Hearing Chairperson may proceed and decide the matter on the evidence available. Sparrows still carries the burden of proving its case; an employee's absence does not shift that burden.
What follows a finding at a hearing
- Where the Hearing Chairperson finds the employee not guilty, no sanction is imposed and the Executive Director lifts any interim measure under §5.4 at once. The record under §9.1 states the finding, and the matter is not relied on against the employee in future.
- Where the Hearing Chairperson finds the employee guilty, the Hearing Chairperson decides the sanction by applying §3.5, and gives it in the decision under §7.6. The sanction is a written warning (§4.3), a final written warning (§4.4) or dismissal (§3.6). In a child-safety matter §6.4 applies.
- A warning takes effect on the date of the decision and is valid for the period in §4.3 or §4.4 from that date. The Executive Director gives the employee the warning in writing, stating the conduct, the date the warning expires and that a repeat may lead to a harsher sanction.
- Dismissal, communicated in writing, with the employee's outstanding documentation and any money owing provided as required by law (Human Resource Policy §13.6 and §13.7).
- A possible finding of unsuitability to work with children. A properly constituted disciplinary hearing under this Code is a forum the Children's Act recognises for this purpose. Where the Hearing Chairperson's finding supports it, the Executive Director ensures the finding is reported for possible inclusion in Part B of the National Child Protection Register, as the Act requires. Regulation 42 of the General Regulations Regarding Children, 2010, requires the notice to reach the Director-General within 21 business days of the finding, on the Notification of Finding of Unsuitability to Work with Children form, in a sealed envelope marked confidential, and the Executive Director sends it.
- A report to the employee's professional body. Where the employee is a child and youth care worker registered with the South African Council for Social Service Professions (SACSSP) and a hearing under this Code finds the employee guilty of an offence, the Executive Director informs the SACSSP in writing, whatever the category of misconduct (regulation 28(2) of the Regulations for Child and Youth Care Workers, Auxiliary Child and Youth Care Workers and Student Child and Youth Care Workers). Where the finding is gross misconduct in a child-safety matter, the Executive Director also reports it to the SACSSP or any other statutory council the employee is registered with, which may act independently of Sparrows' own outcome.
- The employee's right of recourse is unaffected. Nothing in this clause removes an employee's right to refer an unfair-dismissal dispute to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) under the Labour Relations Act.
Confidentiality and records
- Sparrows keeps a written record of every disciplinary matter under this Code — the nature of the concern, the steps taken, and the outcome, with the reasons for the action (Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, item 13) — in the employee's personnel file, retained for as long as the Records and Retention Policy §5.1 requires for personnel records generally (for the duration of employment, and a minimum of three years after it ends). Where the matter also concerns a child — their evidence, their account, or information about them — that information is additionally subject to Sparrows' own confidentiality protections for a child's information, which govern regardless of what this Code itself requires for the employee's own file.
- Information about a child, about the person who raised a concern, and about the employee facing it is shared only as far as the process genuinely requires. Where the information concerns a child specifically, this is consistent with Sparrows' own confidentiality rules for a child's information generally.
- The Executive Director reports every matter of misconduct dealt with under this Code to the Board each month (Human Resource Policy §16.1), sharing only what §9.2 allows.
Review
- This Code is reviewed annually by the Board.