Traditional Male Initiation Policy

Purpose

  1. This policy states Sparrows' position on traditional male initiation for a child in its care, the legal framework that position sits alongside, and what Sparrows does to apply it.

Sparrows' Position

  1. Sparrows does not permit a child in its care to undergo traditional male initiation, without exception. This is not a matter for family consultation, traditional leadership, or a case-by-case judgement — it applies to every child in Sparrows' care, every time, for as long as they remain in Sparrows' care.
  2. This position is not a view on the custom itself, and this policy takes no view on customary male initiation as it is practised in the wider community. It is a safety position, specific to a child for whom Sparrows carries legal responsibility while an initiation school is a facility Sparrows does not run, staff, or supervise. §5 states the basis for that safety concern.
  3. This position also applies to a person placed in Sparrows' care as a child who stays in it after turning 18, for as long as they stay. A child, or such a person, may pursue traditional male initiation once they are no longer in Sparrows' care.

The Legal Framework

  1. The Eastern Cape Customary Male Initiation Practice Act, 2016 (Act 5 of 2016) and the Customary Initiation Act, 2021 (Act 2 of 2021) both set a minimum age below which a person may not attend an initiation school, and both require written consent above it. They do not set the same floor or ask for the same consent.
  2. The Eastern Cape Act (5 of 2016), which governs in the province Sparrows operates in, sets a flat floor of 18. Section 26(2) provides that no person may circumcise or admit a child below the age of 18 to an initiation school, without exception for consent at any age below that. Section 27(10) makes admitting or approving the admission of a child below 18 an offence, punishable on conviction by a fine of up to R10,000, or six months' imprisonment, or both, per initiate. Where a traditional leader or designated person approved the admission and the initiate dies, section 27(11) provides for a charge of conspiracy to murder and up to fifteen years' imprisonment. The Act also requires 21 days' minimum attendance (section 26(5)) and written parental or guardian consent for any admission regardless of age (section 27(3)). Section 26(3) prohibits abducting, forcing, coercing or pressurising a person to attend an initiation school; the Act defines abduction as forcibly taking someone, or enticing a boy, into an initiation school against his will (section 1), and section 27(8) makes any contravention of the Act an offence.
  3. The national Act (2 of 2021), which commenced on 1 September 2021, sets a lower floor of 16, with a conditional band between 16 and 18. Section 28(2) prohibits attendance under 16 outright, subject to section 37(3), which allows provincial legislation to set a higher minimum age. Section 28(3)(a) allows a child between 16 and 18 to attend only with both the child's own written consent and their parent's or guardian's written consent; section 28(3)(b) allows a person 18 or older to attend with their own consent alone. Section 28(6)(a), applying section 12(8) of the Children's Act directly, separately prohibits circumcision of a male child under 16 except for religious or medical purposes.
  4. Sparrows' position at §2.1 is stricter than either Act. It does not depend on a child's age, on which Act applies, or on whether consent has been given.

Relationship to the No-Exclusion Principle

  1. This policy is not an exception to, or in conflict with, Sparrows' settled position that a child in its care is never excluded, punished, or expelled (the Child Protection Policy §3). Declining to permit a child's attendance at a facility Sparrows does not run or supervise is a safety boundary Sparrows sets in advance for every child alike, not a response to anything a child has done — the same category of boundary as a child needing permission to leave the property (the Perimeter Security Policy §4.1), not a disciplinary measure.
  2. Where a child, or a person to whom §2.3 applies, tells a member of staff that they want to undergo initiation, that member of staff hears them, takes them seriously and explains honestly, including why the answer is no while they remain in Sparrows' care, and tells the Social Worker. It is not dismissed or treated as a discipline matter.

The Risk This Policy Responds To

  1. Initiation-related deaths are an ongoing toll concentrated in the province Sparrows operates in. The Eastern Cape Provincial Initiation Coordinating Committee told Parliament's Portfolio Committee on Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs on 21 February 2023 that 51,601 boys were enrolled in the province's 2022 summer season and 23 initiates died. That was a higher toll than the previous winter season's 11 deaths from 10,794 boys. It also said that most causes of death were related to dehydration. The Head of the Eastern Cape Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs told the same committee of a child whose screening results showed that he could not be taken to an initiation school: his family took him anyway, and he died within two days.
  2. This is the reason the position at §2.1 is not qualified by consent, family wishes, or the specific initiation school proposed: the risk this policy responds to is not a risk that better consent paperwork or a better-run individual school removes, and Sparrows is not in a position to inspect, supervise, or vouch for the safety of a facility it has no role in running.

Telling the Child, the Family and the Designated Social Worker

  1. As part of the information a child receives on admission (the Admission Policy §5.2), the Social Worker tells the child that Sparrows does not permit traditional male initiation while they are in Sparrows' care, and why, in words suited to their age and understanding.
  2. With the information a child's parent or guardian receives on admission (the Admission Policy §5.1), the Social Worker gives them, and the Designated Social Worker, a written statement of §2.1.
  3. Where a parent, guardian or other family member asks for the child to undergo initiation, the Social Worker explains that the answer is no while the child is in Sparrows' care, and why, and tells the Designated Social Worker.

Supporting a Child's Heritage

  1. Declining initiation does not limit a child's right to care that respects, protects and promotes their cultural, religious and linguistic heritage, and their right to learn about and maintain it (General Regulations Regarding Children, regulation 73(i)).
  2. The Social Worker records in the child's individual development plan how the child keeps and learns about their heritage, with the child's participation and, as far as is reasonably possible, their family's. The plan is reviewed under the Admission Policy §6.2.
  3. Initiation is not one of the cultural activities a child may choose under the Admission Policy §7.2 while they are in Sparrows' care.

Leave of Absence and Leaving Sparrows

  1. Sparrows does not grant a leave of absence under the Discharge Policy §3 for a child to undergo initiation.
  2. Where Sparrows learns during a leave of absence that the child is to be taken to an initiation school, Sparrows cancels the leave, asks for the child's return (the Discharge Policy §3.2) and tells the Designated Social Worker.
  3. Before a child or young person leaves Sparrows permanently, the Social Worker tells them, and the person they are going to live with where there is one, in writing, about the minimum ages and consent the law requires (§3) and the risk to a child's health and life (§5).

If a Child Is Taken, or Someone Tries to Take Them

  1. Where anyone attempts to take a child from Sparrows' care to an initiation school, or a child is enticed to leave for one, without Sparrows' consent, this is reported immediately to the Shift Leader. The Shift Leader tells the Social Worker and the Executive Director, and it is recorded in the Incident Register (the Emergency and Crisis Management Policy §4.2). Where the child has left, it is also treated as a missing child under that policy's §2.2, regardless of who is responsible for it.
  2. This may also breach the Eastern Cape Act's section 26(3), which prohibits abducting, forcing, coercing or pressurising a person to attend an initiation school, and, separately, may meet the mandatory reporting threshold at the Child Protection Policy §4.2. Neither the duty in §9.1 nor the duty to report waits for the other.
  3. Where a child returns from an initiation school, however they came to be there, Sparrows takes them for medical care at once if they are injured, unwell or dehydrated, tells the Designated Social Worker, and does not exclude or punish them (the Child Protection Policy §3). The Executive Director reports a serious injury under the Emergency and Crisis Management Policy §4.4.

Review

  1. This policy is reviewed annually by the Board.